| CORPORATE STRATEGY |
December/
January 2004 |
HIGH TEA
How a 'boutique' tea producer and
its CFO are reinventing the rules for promoting Asian brands.
By Mindee Hansen
"Green Gold" helped keep Sri
Lanka afloat through nearly three decades of civil war. Amid
the bloody cultural divide that fueled the conflict, tea offered
Sri Lanka a reason to be proud of its heritage. The tea is
still known as "Ceylon", the old name given by the British
to the island nation, and it has kept its cachet, and price
premium, regardless of the political situation.
Dilhan Fernando, son of the founder of
Dilmah Teas, Merrill Fernando, wants to keep building on that
fame. The Fernando family company, Dilmah Teas, built its
brand for pure Ceylon tea amid civil conflict, competition
from low-cost upstarts, and increasingly powerful multinational
corporations. Now, amid a subcontinent of brewing high-tech
wunderkind brand names, Dilmah's owners and its CFO Minetta
Perera are vying for recognition on the global stage. It's
all the more remarkable because the effort is based on the
ancient business of offering thirsty wanderers a glorious,
aromatic cup of tea.
"Many tea producers are impressed by Dilmah
and are a little envious of what they have been able to do,"
says Glenn A. John, publisher of Tea and Coffee Asia, a trade
magazine covering the industry. "Their tea has a personal
character, and that has helped it become a success."
The company had sales of US$18 million
last year and employs about 1,600 people - not counting the
tea pickers who work on the estates - in two units, one public
and one private. Ceylon Tea Services (CTS) was the first tea
company to list on the Colombo Stock Exchange and now ranks
thirty-ninth in terms of market capitalization. The private
company, MJF Exports, is a bulk tea exporting company selling
its tea to be used by other companies in their private label
brands. Both businesses have a rich cashflow. Perera, who
has been on the job for two years, has been able to extract
terms that demand cash before delivery from risky markets
from Russia to Uzbekistan - which account for 40 percent of
Dilmah's sales. Tough payment terms with the other 60 percent
- customers in Australia, Europe, and Middle East - have helped
keep the company's larder of cash sufficiently stocked.
Fernando' strategy could be summed up
in the phrase 'small is beautiful.' Going against conventional
wisdom, which advises that companies concentrate on core activities
and cede control of peripheral businesses along the supply
chain, Fernando has sought, wherever feasible, to own Dilmah's
supply chain. As for marketing, Dilmah's executives run everything
from Colombo. The thinking is that word-of-mouth, clever market
entry, and strategic dips into brand advertising here and
there can work wonders for boutique brands, in the way that
some coffee purveyors have gained global recognition. It seems
to be working.
The first step, in 2000, was to create
a holding company, called MJF Holdings, for Dilmah's investments.
That same year, the company bought 70 percent of Forbes &
Walker, one of the oldest and best-known tea brokerages in
Colombo, where the world's biggest tea auctions are held.
Tea brokers are a critical link in the tea chain because they
buy, sell, and grade tea. The company then bought shares in
three plantation management companies in 2002, shortly after
they were handed over to private management by the Sri Lankan
government. These strategic alliances allow Dilmah's quality-control
experts to consult with the plantation managers about methods
in growing the tea, as well as the type and variety of the
crop.
"These plantations are not what you would
call money-spinners for us - they are long-term investments,"
says Perera. "Mr. Fernando wants certain teas grown and the
plantation owners want to tap into his knowledge about what
tea buyers around the world want," says Perera.
In an economy long wracked by war, Sri
Lankan tea is notorious for languishing amid shipping delays.
Unlike fine wine, tea doesn't improve with age. In trying
to sell a premium tea, having the green stuff grow stale on
ships or in warehouses was a major problem. Dilmah decided
that it was safer to produce its own packaging, and purchased
a small company in Sri Lanka, introducing methods of vacuum
packing and temperature control that are now sought after
by other tea producers. Dilmah runs its packaging operation
on a just-in-time basis, in an effort to lower inventory costs,
shorten the working capital cycle and lower the cost of managing
stock.
"Our materials have to be the highest
quality, and they must be attractive," says Perera, adding
that the strategic alliance in the packing equipment gave
Dilmah Teas more control and lower costs. "Before we made
the investments, Sri Lanka simply did not have the packing
facilities we needed for our brand." Dilmah doesn't have its
own distribution network, but maintains close ties with them
via associated offices in its primary markets. To convince
distributors that Sri Lankan tea is worth the premium, the
company held a six-day meeting with them this year, including
three days in the field, explaining how Ceylon tea is grown."
Small, Sweet and Global
Dilmah's methods have so far been well
suited to its owners' ambition of building global brand awareness.
Dilmah Teas is now one of the top three tea brands in Australia,
where it holds 12 percent of the market share, and New Zealand,
where it holds 21 percent. It's made headway in Russia, where
it holds a 3.4 percent market share. Unilever's Lipton brand,
by comparison, has 11.8 percent.
Ironically, Sri Lanka's turbulent decades
of war have actually given the nation's producers a helping
hand. To survive, the producers modernized and increased their
global competitiveness by sharing information and collaborating
in planting and harvesting methods to insure that Ceylon tea
retained its premium reputation. "We share secrets other companies
wouldn't share with competitors," says Fernando.
In contrast, after the collapse of the
former Soviet states, where Indian producers sold much of
their tea, Indian tea fell into a cycle of declining productivity
and quality. Government labor policies put added pressure
on the producers' cost base. Today, it costs US$1.50 to produce
2.2 pounds of Indian tea, which sells for about US$1. Plantations
are closing, accompanied by occasional outbursts of violence.
Premium tea, with its associations
with polite society, would seem a refined arena in a world
swooning with trade wars. But Fernando sees peril here, too.
"If we fail," he says, "globalization will dictate that there
will be no hope for the Sri Lankan tea industry." But for
now, being a small and canny runner around the behemoths has
its satisfactions. 
Mindee Hansen is a freelance writer
based in Hong Kong
|